L'Oreal ParisVoluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, Black (Packaging May Vary)

I started using this eyeliner years ago. Haven’t found anyone who makes them better.

I’ve used this pencil for years. Love it!!!!

This is the best eye liner I've ever used. It's soft enough to blend or keep in a smooth line. Also great to fill in eyebrow gaps.

Nice quality, beautiful dark color. It is like oily type is really good.

This came in perfect condition and worked very well. The pencil is soft and smudgey (it's meant to be) easy to apply to the waterline. Since I use it for the waterline and not for a smokey eye, the smudginess is a double-edged sword, since some of the liner migrated down below one eye. I guess I need to use a really light hand. But after I removed the runny bit, it lasted the night without running further. It was cool weather, though. I'm quite happy with this pencil overall. I just have to be careful with the runniness. I'm sure that means it blends well for this who do like a smokey eye. My eyes are too small and deep set for that. It's black but not harsh. The formula is nice and smooth. A quality product. I will come back and edit this if I have more issues with running when the weather heats up. I am including a picture, although it's on my upper waterline so not super visible. But I'm only wearing the liner (upper waterline only) and some mascara on my eyes, and I think it did a nice job of making them more intense.

Really nice eye pencil for the money it’s a little bit thick but otherwise great

The absolute best kohl eyeliner ..comes on nice and dark I am so impressed with this product

I love the size, the ease of application, the color, and how bold it is, but it smudges and runs so easily that you have very little time to enjoy it before needing to reapply. Have yet to figure out a curve to avoid this (I do not have oily skin.)