WonderskinEyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Black Glitter Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge ProofClimatePartner certified

I've tried a gazillion eyeliners and this is definitely in the top one or two. It definitely stays on even when I'm outside and it literally glides on. They have so many colors and it comes off easily enough with make up remover.

This is the ONLY waterproof eyeliner pencil that I have EVER found that wouldn't leave smears under my eyes!! I absolutely love it. Tested it by wearing it overnight and it didn't rub off except for the outer corners of my eyes, as I am a side sleeper. Just wish it came with a sharpener that would make more of a fine line. I wasn't able to smear it after putting it on, that just didn't work. For long wear, it works great. I am 70 and have hooded eyes. Plan on trying other methods of applying it, such as with a fine brush, as I will never buy another brand of pencil again. This one is awesome!

This is a really good product however it does not stay on as well as it shows in the videos I've seen. I don't know if it's just my oily skin or if it's just not as good as they claim. It does stay on relatively well however when I rubbed my eye the other day because it was itchy it still came off and smudged. I do like the color and it goes on nice and smooth. You do need to buy a sharpener whenever you buy this as it does not twist up. Whenever you wash your face it does come off well and doesn't leave a lot of streaking or marks, I just wash my face with water and microfiber facial cloths and it comes off just fine.

This eyeliner is great. Longwear and easy to apply with a creamy formula. My problem is that it doesn't sharpen. Just breaks off in the sharpener.

Absolutely love this eyeliner! Easy to apply, stays all day! But there are two things you will need to get the most out of this.1. It's hard to sharpen with a regular sharpener. Get the wonderskin eyeliner sharpener, it works!2. If you do tend to smudge a bit throughout the day, try brushing a light coat of your go-to setting powder over it to get it to behave.Will definitely be purchasing again! ❤️

This eyeliner is amazing! It glides on very easily. The pencil is soft, and then…..in about 30 seconds it becomes smudge proof. I highly recommend it!

Nice eye liner, goes on smooth, nice colorWill buy more

Pros: This product has great pigmentation and has not faded after 15 hours. Beautiful color!Cons: I found this product does not apply smoothly. I had to work quickly to smudge, blend, and clean the rest of the bumpy application with an q-tip before it set. Otherwise, I would have had a “connect the dots” look going on. To address, I tried sharpening to expose a fresh part of the pencil. My waterline was clean and dry. And still a blotchy look that required quick work to look good. Tomorrow I will try warming up the pencil with a quick blast under my hair dryer. It’s a lot of work for an eyeliner that advertises the product to have “Truglide technology for a butter-like application.” I would agree that it applies like butter…butter that’s cold, dry, and a bit crumbly. I almost wonder if the liner I received is near the end of its shelf life?The reason why this product got 4 stars from me is because it does have staying power.-and it does seem to be waterproof. Typically after 15 hours my eyeliner has totally disappeared. But sure do wish it applies as easily as advertised.