Make Up For EverAqua Resist Color Pencil - 1 Graphite for Women - 0.04 oz Eyeliner

This is my second purchase of this make-up product. Worth every penny. You get what you pay for....not saying that some economical makeup products aren't any good or high price products are guaranteed to be wonderful. But this pencil I will continue to buy forever as long as I wear makeup. It is long lasting, heavy and dark, applies easily. I am glad I tried it. Thank you Amazon!

This eyeliner pencil stays in the waterline very well. It’s not good on the eyelids because it will smudge and transfer. If you need a great waterline eyeliner, this one works very well and is long lasting.

This eyeliner is very good. Smooth going on and lasts all day. My only complaint is the cost. I think it is a little overpriced.

This is NOT water-proof or smudge-proof, but for $20 some bucks it sure should of been!

Finally I found the best eyeliner, is smooth , thin tip , easy to slide and last all day , is expensive but is worth it , i hope last long time for the price

This pencil works pretty well for not smudging. I've had a hard time finding smudge-proof eye liner. It still smudges a little bit 2nd half of day but not terrible.

Goes on easily ~ stays on and stays put ~ is not a harsh looking product ~ has a soft effect and looks very natural. I use it on my top lid along the waterline. I've used Thrive eyeliner for several years and always loved it, but it is a bit harsh looking and this one has a softer, muted look so I'll definitely be ordering it again as needed.

Doesn't stay on as advertised --total waste of money.