jane iredale Eye Pencil Mineral Based with Conditioning Oils and Waxes Natural Pigments & Long Lasting Colors Vegan & Cruellty-Free Eye Makeup

This is probably my favorite eyeliner ever! I have always had trouble finding an eyeliner I like in any brand, any type, and any price range. The pencils were either too light or too thick or smeared or faded too easily, and I have an even worse time with liquids and gels. Unfortunately, I prefer my appearance with eyeliner. Lately, I've been attempting to make many of my own products out of organic ingredients; but knowing my luck with commercial eyeliners, I presumed my anything I made would require many trials and errors. So I did some research and decided this was a brand I'd be comfortable using. This is the smoothest, easiest to apply, least smearing, perfect dark line drawing eyeliner I have ever used, and it's not filled with a ton of toxic chemicals I can't even pronounce! (And it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes or skin at all.) I will absolutely continue to buy this and happily recommend it.

I love all Jane Iredale products. This glides on smoothly, doesn't smudge or wear off, and gives a great color.**Update 1/8/2014I recently purchased the color Taupe. Since Amazon only lets you review one color of an item, I wanted to add my comments about the Taupe. It is the perfect color for eyes and lips. It is a very subtle brown for your eyes and a little darker on the lips. It is great for the "I'm not wearing any makeup, I'm just naturally beautiful" look. I pair the lip liner with the sugar and butter lip duo set and it gives you a perfect neutral color with a tiny tint of color. On the eyes it gives you some color without being too made up or overbearing. Great choice for an all in one lip and eye pencil. I'll update as I purchase additional colors.I currently own black/grey, great for that smokey eye look, beautiful for green eyes. Basic brown, a darker brown for more dramatic eyes, black/brown, which was my original review, good for dramatic smokey eyes, Nude, a good color for eyes and lips. On the lips it is a brownish mauve and on the eyes it is a brown with a hint of pink, which looks good with pink, brown, or purple shadows. Lastly, Spice, which I use for a lip liner. It is a lighter brown with a lot of pink undertones. It goes great with lip colors along the lines of Sarah and Sandra as well as the lip sugar and butter duo. I am blonde, blue/green eyes (they change), and light to medium skin with olive undertones. I hope this thorough review helps!

Good quality, non toxic, soft

Easy for creating a smoky eye. Disappointed it didn’t come with a sharpener, but that’s on me for not reading.

Very easy to apply. Forgiving and easily reapplied.

It was smooth on the eyelid, and the color was basic brown with no sparkle like in the picture. I fell asleep for like 6 hours with it on and no smudging or transfer at all. It didnt move. So thats what im looking for in an eyeline. Good color, easy to use, and please dont budge. So this one wins. Id love it to be less expensive. Cause 20 bucks for a pencil liner is just excessive to me, but ill have it forever cause i dont use eyeliner that much. Im ok with this though, glad i bought it.

I decided to get this eyeliner in taupe and the color is absolutely beautiful; I have light blue eyes so most eyeliners look a little too stark against my eyes/skin, so this was perfect! Or so I thought. I could tell right away that this is one of those eyeliners that you have to go back several times to build up the color, but unfortunately for me, it will he color never got more concentrated after the second pass. Also, I have an issue with my eyeliners fading away super early and this one does the same thing. By noon it is barely even then anymore. I am not sure if that is a “me” problem or an issue with the product. Overall, the color is super flattering and I really wanted this to become my staple eyeliner. Sadly this can’t be the case unless they reformulate the product. I hope they do.

Good quality.Not dry. So can be slippery.