Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil - 202 Xtreme Black

Very black. Stays put and wears all day

Last a long time, nice color, stays all day.

I tried another of this brands eye liner and loved it. I couldn’t find that exact one so I tried this one and it smeared within the first 30 minutes. Very disappointed

This eyeliner is terrible! It goes on clumpy and way too thick. If you try to draw a line at the lash base, it is so thick it mashes your eyelashes down. There is no margin for error - you get any in the wrong spot and you can't remove it without completely removing all makeup. It takes serious effort to get all of it off at the end of the day. (multiple applications of makeup remover!) If any is left behind you wake up with black smears all over your face. Given how difficult it is to remove, it is shockingly NOT smudge proof! If you sweat at all, or your eyes tear, be prepared for the racoon look. Massive waste of money!