COVERGIRL Ink It! By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner Aquamarine Ink 240, .006 oz (packaging may vary)

Just like my heading states, I love the aquamarine color of this eyeliner. I like to try different shades of eyeliner such as violet, blue and now this one. My eyes are blue so using different shades makes putting on makeup more fun. My only complaint, which I've had with all pencil liners I've used, is sometimes small pieces break off too easily. But since this happens with all my pencils I still gave it 5 stars.

I need more of this color!

I use this to line my eyelids. I love the color, it makes my eyes pop. The application is very smooth too.

I bought this to replace the one that I have used for the past year, as it's not available in stores anymore. The one I had before was silky, went on very nice and was a pretty blue color, this new one is listed as the same name and color as the other one but they are completely different. The new one is a lighter color and really dry and crumbly, even the tips are completely different. I don't know if covergirl changed their formula or if these are just really old ones. Do not buy.

The first one I ordered was the exact color I wanted Aquamarine, when I reordered it the color said Aquamarine on the pencil but it’s not...it’s more Navy Blue. Very disappointed!

I have another one but it is black. This one, is dry. Takes a lot to get it on. Almost like it is older stock but cannot verify that.

I guess Im old school and like to match my eye liner to the shirt I am wearing so when I wear blue, adding a bit to my eyeliner is a nice addition. I always get compliments so I guess it looks ok! I like it and that is what really matters.

Vibrant color but it keeps breaking! :(