Seraphine Botanicals Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner - Long Lasting Liner Pen Brush Ultra Fine Tip Eye Gel Pigmented Makeup Black Smudge Resistant (Liquid Coal)

This eyeliner goes on super smooth and cover the area on the first try. I use it daily for defining my cat eye and lining my top eyelid. The liquid makes it harder to put on the lower lid. I have this eyeliner on a routine delivery and I hope that it never gets discontinued. Thanks for reading my review, hope it helps with your eye makeup decision.

I'm so sensitive to chemicals, and this one does the best for my cat eye without making my eyes water all day!

Great product !!I have tried so many eyeliners in my lifetime. I am 60 now.This is by far the best one. Cross between a wand and a marker. Easily applied and stays all day.

I love this product! My eyes tend to run ( tear) throughout the day and because this is waterproof I no longer have my eyeliner smudging all day and the color stays all day until I remove it. Even with it being waterproof it is very easy to remove. It also never smudges on the top of my eyelids like all other eyeliners do. The point is a perfect size and goes on smooth and perfect every time. I wish they sold different colors !!

Packaging is great and it looks good. I just don’t like how it’s not as good as I had hoped it would be.

This eyeliner is truly amazing. It does not smudge, it lasts a very long time, and simple to use. You will not go wrong with it.

Says it's water resistant but I've never had a problem with it. I'd gladly say waterproof. Doesn't smudge or smear. Had a sturdy felt tip for precision.

This has the perfect firm tip to it so you can use it on your lash line while keeping your eyes open. You don't have to drag it across your skin which doesn't work well for hooded, aging eyes. Comes out super black and easy to do a winged line. Absolutely the best and I've used so many.