Peanut Butter & Co.Old Fashioned Crunchy Peanut Butter, Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Vegan, No Sugar Added, 16 Ounce (Pack of 1)

I’m on a high protein, low carbohydrate, diet, I love this peanut butter. It doesn’t have any garbage ingredients like all the commercial brands and it’s pretty much the same price, the taste is great. I just add a little bit of sugar substitute, pick whichever one you like, but it’s fine

Great taste. Great size. Great value

I tried this brand because it was on Binging with Babish. He ranked this brand very highly, with most of his top ranks going to this brand.My experience is very different. This was the worst peanut butter I can remember having.It's wet and runny, so much that if you scoop spoonful out, and tilt the spoon it will pour off. Almost nothing will be left on the spoon. The texture in your mouth is even worse. Wet and sticky all at once.Next, the flavor is terrible. Bland and bad tasting all at once. Not much else to say.

UPDATED 4/20/23: I Purchased the white chocolate version and got a case of six for just a few pennies over $20 which I think is an awesome deal because each jar is 16 ounces.The last time I purchased this peanut butter it was just regular with no extra flavor and that review is below this one. however I think that the white chocolate added to the peanut butter puts the flavor way over the top! In simple terms: I LOVE IT! 😍It is still extremely soft but this time I used my hand blender that has a frothing attachment so I was able to get way down deep into the jar and all along the sides and really mix it up thoroughly. Prior to this I was just using a knife and manually mixing it. I still have to keep it in the refrigerator and it’s still much softer than normal storebrand peanut butter (like Jiffy) but the price and the flavor makes up for that. But if you really want a stiff peanut butter I don’t think that this is gonna work for you. I’m going to keep it in the refrigerator overnight on the top shelf so it’s the coldest and if it’s stiffens up more than I am thinking it will, I’ll come back and edit this.———————-ORIGINAL REVIEW ON REGULAR/UNFLAVORED VERSION: The flavor is good but even after keeping it in the refrigerator within just a moment of opening the jar and starting to spread it out, it gets so soft and so soupy that it is just too runny. I like a peanut butter that spreads and stays stiff on the bread and this is just too soft. It’s really too bad because the flavor is very good.

I adore this peanut butter!

This peanut butter is really runny and the oil separates to the top after only 24 hours.

This is my new pick for Peanut Butter! I've been searching for a simple crunchy peanut butter with no sugar for a while since my local grocer stopped carrying Adam's No-Stir Crunchy Peanut Butter. Those were some sad times trying other options that just didn't live up to the taste, but this peanut butter is a saving grace! This is the closest alternative with the best value that I've been able to find. I see several others have complained about oil, but that's what's in Peanut Butter. Take out the oil and you end up with something else added that is potentially worse. If I haven't used the jar in a while I just stir a little and then use what I need. My family loves this stuff!!! To save on the plastic jars, I would buy a larger container, or perhaps in a tube. I have enough jars to store all my hardware, I don't need more.

I wish there was an option for TEN STARS. Not only is it the BEST CRUNCHY peanut butter I have, in 76 years on the planet, had the good fortune of sliding in my mouth but its SUGAR FREE !!!!!! It ABSOLUTELY BLOWS the likes of Jif, Peter Pan and Skippy out of the water. They are not even in the same ballpark as this magically SCRUMPTIOUS CRUNCHY FLAVOR PACKED DELIGHT !!! Get you some, thank me later !!!