GarnierErase It All Makeup Cleansing Balm with Hyaluronic Acid, Replumping Facial Cleanser and Makeup Remover, 4.2 Oz

I have sensitive skin and after having skin patch testing at dermatologist’s, learned I have a severe allergy to fragrances. They recommend if I want to use a perfume, try patch testing the fragrance. But was advised to avoid cosmetics and body care products that contain fragrance. You have no clue what they put in those fragrance blends and the manufacturers can change formulas from year to year. Having suffered discomfort, swelling, redness and rashes over the years, plus lost $$ on products that don’t work, I shop for fragrance free products. I also expect them to work, and not cost too much. This Garnier makeup remover is effective, feels soothing and is a great value. It’s a good first step in a double cleanse. A little goes a long way.

Really good makeup cleansing balm, especially for the price. Emulsifies with water, easy to wash off. And doesn’t leave my skin dry at all. I think I’ll be a repeat customer! The amount of product is also pretty decent, good value for money especially more so if on sale.No spatula to get the product out though, however that’s not a concern for me since i had kept one from a previous product I used up.

It work wonderfully. The scent is awful. Smells like petroleum. I would totally give 5 stars but the scent is what will keep me from buying again.

LET ME TELL YOU! I LOVEEEEEE THIS STUFF! I really do. I used to only take my makeup off in the shower, but there are times when I don't need to take a full on shower but I needed a clean and easy removal method. I actually started using Garnier micellar water to remove makeup and it seemed like I was going through so much of it and for some reason it made my face hurt and feel extremely sensitive afterwards. I had a trip coming up and while looking for my to go items I came across a makeup balm, so I searched for balms and Garnier had this. This has made the clean up so easy, the product goes a long way, wipes off easy and doesnt make my face hurt at all afterwards. Ive even gotten some of this in my eyes while getting off my mascara and while it made my vision a little fuzzy for a few moments, it didnt sting, and unlike the micellar water . When I wake up the next morning after having used this my skin looks amazing as it normally does. I used to have a weird dullness on my skin after wearing makeup and removing it, I thought it was the makeup itself but literally it was whatever was in the micellar water.

Got this after I was tired and didn’t like makeup remover wipes anymore. This takes off ALL the makeup and my face feels so much better than using the wipes. I use this and then a gentle cleanser and it works great.

I like the elf one better. This has a weird smell. It is thicker and a slightly off texture. Kind of like a vaseline texture but not quite. Doesn’t come off as easily and even my eye makeup is more of a struggle to remove with this. Elf is more expensive so I was trying this. I just think elf is superior as a makeup remover and the texture isn’t so synthetic. I will still be able to use it until it’s gone but I won’t purchase again.

This is my favorite makeup remover. It works extremely well with little scrubbing. Great for sensitive skin. It also doubles as a mask because it has hyaluronic acid in it. The amount for the price is also a great deal. I have this on subscription.

I’ve used cold cream for years and still do in my eyes, but this cleanser works really well at breaking down and cleaning my makeup better than the cold cream. I no longer break out bc my face wasn’t getting clean enough. I don’t love the scent it has, but it doesn’t stop me from using it.